So MY fear is a totally irrational fear, unlike so many of you who have posted, whose horses are so green or unpredictable, and have developed some goofy habits, or those who are brand new to riding and understandably afraid of the unknown.
I'm a good rider with a good horse and I'm still a nervous wreck.
I have been riding for years and did lots of equitrekking before I bought my horse two years ago; he is an 11 year old Appendix gelding who started out Western before I got him but took to jumping like a duck to water. He had a very bad attitude until I treated him for ulcers on a hunch, and since then, he has been a pretty agreeable guy. He is an alpha in the pasture. He'd be an alpha with me if I let him, but he is well schooled and takes discipline fine. Under saddle he's always been good, if maybe sometimes a little lazy.
And for absolutely no reason at all, I am terrified riding him away from home. Terrified. I'm a good rider and he's a great horse but not totally bombproof; I've stuck to him during some big spooks, and have gotten him back in hand. These spooks were at totally reasonable things, like a hunter in camouflage jumping out of nearby tree without warning, or a strange dog bursting out of the bushes. I just bought a trailer expressly so we could go do things, but I'm scared to! Incidentally, he's a good shipper, getting on and off the trailer and riding without fuss.
I've fallen off him and off of other horses plenty of times, and luckily I haven't ever been really hurt. He is well enough trained so that he can be ridden in a plain snaffle on the trails and controlled easily. He prefers to lead on the trails and frets and jigs if he has to stay in back. But really, he doesn't do anything bad ever! But I'll be out on the trails and he'll toss his head or speed up a little, and I'll have a total panic attack. Sometimes I've even gotten off and led him (and he follows me obediently because, of course, absolutely nothing is wrong.) God forbid he gets a little excited about some minor thing; I just about pass out.
I dream about going to horse shows and hunter paces and cantering down the trails, jumping fallen logs, but I'm too afraid to--I'm afraid he's going to freak out and run away or something. I know I'm skilled enough to probably ride it out without a problem if he did--does anybody have any suggestions for me?